Visit Us
Address
2156 Bellmore Ave, Bellmore,
NY 11710
Phone Number
516-242-9681
Hours
Open Every Day
11 a.m. - 6 p.m. ET
PRIVATE EVENTS
Packages are available for birthdays, graduations and more!
Elevate your next celebration by reserving a private event at our sports cards shop! Whether you’re celebrating a birthday or planning a unique get-together for fellow sports enthusiasts, our sports cards shop offers the perfect blend of excitement and exclusivity. Enjoy a private space filled with an extensive selection of sports cards, where you and your guests can trade, browse, and even participate in special activities curated just for your event. Our friendly and knowledgeable team will be on hand to assist, ensuring a memorable experience for all.
Book your private event today and create unforgettable memories surrounded by the thrill of sports cards! Fill out the form below and we’ll be in touch with availability and pricing details!
Rob ansalone
A Merrick native and lifelong sports fan, Rob Ansalone is bringing Replay Sports Cards to Bellmore. After a career in insurance and experience owning a gym franchise, Rob is turning his passion for collecting into a welcoming shop for Long Island collectors.
His goal is to create a place where fans and families can connect, buy, sell, trade and grade cards—and share their love of the hobby.
WANT TO WIN SWEET PRIZES?
Be the first to learn about new product drops, updates and future giveaways. Drop in your info. to stay in the know and enter for a chance to score free cards, boxes and Replay Sports Cards gear.